Comparison · prices checked on 28 October 2026

Magento vs Shopify: which one suits you?

Magento and Shopify are both serious e-commerce software, but you buy something different with each. Shopify rents you a ready-made shop with the maintenance included, Magento gives you an engine that you set up yourself or with an agency. Here you can read where Magento and Shopify are each stronger, what they really cost and what you take with you when you switch.

Compared honestly, including where the other is better

What is the difference between Magento and Shopify?

Shopify is a hosted e-commerce platform: you pay per month, and hosting, security and updates are included. Magento is open source e-commerce software that you host and have built yourself, with Adobe Commerce as the paid edition. Shopify is quicker to launch and easier to manage, Magento gives more freedom for large catalogues, complex B2B and custom work, but needs a development team.
  • Choose Shopify if you want to start selling quickly and would rather not handle maintenance yourself.
  • Choose Magento if you are building a large or complex shop, with lots of custom work or B2B, and you have an agency or your own developers.
  • Still unsure? Do not compare the licence, compare what build, hosting, apps and maintenance cost you over three years.

Magento and Shopify side by side

FeatureMagentoShopify
Type of systemOpen source (Magento Open Source) or paid (Adobe Commerce), self-hosted or hosted by AdobeHosted e-commerce platform
Software priceOpen Source free, Adobe Commerce on requestFrom €21 per month excl. VAT billed yearly (Basic)
HostingArrange it yourself, or Adobe Commerce on CloudIncluded
Transaction feesNone from Magento, only from your payment providerNone with Shopify Payments, otherwise 2% extra on Basic
iDEALThrough a payment extension of your choiceThrough Shopify Payments: €0.29 per payment
MultilingualYes, multiple store views in the coreYes, Shopify Markets built in, translation through Shopify's free Translate & Adapt app
B2BExtensive in Adobe Commerce, in Open Source only through extensionsBuilt in, up to 3 catalogues on Basic
Maintenance and updatesYou or your agency, including version upgradesHandled by Shopify
ExportingFull database and code under your own control, except with Adobe Commerce as a Cloud ServiceProducts, customers and orders as CSV

Where Shopify is stronger

Shopify is the fastest route from idea to working shop. You pick a theme, add your products and connect your domain, and hosting, security and updates are no longer your problem. According to Shopify's pricing page that starts at €21 per month excl. VAT billed yearly, with iDEAL at €0.29 per payment through Shopify Payments (as of 28 October 2026).

Shopify is also friendlier for your team. The admin works without a manual, and there is an app for almost every need. A shop with a few hundred products and a small team usually has enough with Shopify, without needing a developer.

Where Magento is stronger

Magento is built for shops that do not fit a standard mould. You run multiple stores, languages and currencies from one installation, and because you control the code and the database, you can build pricing logic, checkout and ERP integrations exactly the way your business works. According to Adobe, company accounts, quotes, approvals and payment on account are part of Adobe Commerce, the paid edition (as of 28 October 2026).

On top of that, Magento Open Source takes no percentage of your revenue. It is free, and you choose your own hosting and payment provider. With high revenue and your own development team, that freedom counts for a lot. Small caveat: that freedom does need a team that can carry it.

What Magento and Shopify cost

Shopify charges a fixed amount per month. According to Shopify's pricing page, billed yearly that is €21 for Basic, €59 for Grow and €289 for Advanced, and Plus starts at €2,100 per month. Those amounts are excluding VAT. With Shopify Payments in the Netherlands you pay €0.29 per iDEAL payment (€0.15 on Plus) and on Basic 1.9% + €0.25 per standard online card payment (lower on Grow and Advanced; Amex and international cards 2.9% + €0.25). If you use another payment provider, Shopify charges 2% extra per transaction on Basic (as of 28 October 2026). Paid apps and themes come on top.

With Magento the software is free, but the rest is not. You pay for hosting that is powerful enough, for the build by an agency or your own developers, for extensions and above all for maintenance and version upgrades. Adobe Commerce has no public price: according to Adobe you request a quote (as of 28 October 2026). For a small shop Shopify is therefore almost always cheaper, and that only tips with high revenue and lots of custom work.

Switching, and maintaining Magento

Magento needs regular upgrades. According to the Adobe Commerce lifecycle policy, every version gets three years of standard support: 2.4.9 was released on 12 May 2026 and has standard support until 31 May 2029. For 2.4.6, standard support ended on 11 August 2026. Adobe Commerce customers keep extended support until 31 August 2027; that extension does not apply to Magento Open Source (as of 28 October 2026). If you do not keep up, you face an upgrade project every few years.

Moving from Magento to Shopify is possible with migration tools that transfer products, customers and orders, but custom work and extensions have to be rebuilt. The other way round, you export your products, customers and orders from Shopify as CSV, as Shopify's help centre describes, and the theme stays behind. With 301 redirects from every old URL to the new one, you carry over your Google rankings as well as possible.

Magento or Shopify: which one to choose?

Choose Shopify if you want to start selling quickly, have a manageable range and do not want to manage your own developers. You pay per month and per app, and in return Shopify handles the technology.

Choose Magento if your shop is large or complex, with multiple stores, extensive B2B arrangements or many integrations with your own systems, and if there is an agency or team behind it that knows Magento. You pay more for build and maintenance, and you get a shop that does exactly what you want.

Still unsure? Then Shopify is usually the safer starting point, because anyone who needs Magento has usually already hit the limits of a standard platform.

And if neither fits

Sometimes the honest answer is: neither. If you do not want to pay per app or run upgrade projects, and you keep running into separate systems for stock, point of sale, email and customer contact, Magento or Shopify only moves that problem around. That is what Neuramerce was built for, one hosted system with those parts already inside. How it compares to each of them, you can read in Magento vs Neuramerce and Shopify vs Neuramerce, and all platforms are on comparing e-commerce software.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions about Magento and Shopify.

Not better, just different. Magento is stronger for large, complex shops with lots of custom work, multiple stores or extensive B2B. Shopify is stronger for almost everything else: quicker to launch, easier to manage and no maintenance of your own.
Billed yearly, €21 for Basic, €59 for Grow and €289 for Advanced, excl. VAT, and Plus from €2,100 per month. On top of that you pay payment processing fees, such as €0.29 per iDEAL payment through Shopify Payments (€0.15 on Plus), and any paid apps. As of 28 October 2026.
Magento Open Source is free to download. You do pay for hosting, build, extensions and maintenance. Adobe Commerce, the paid edition with extensive B2B features among other things, is priced on request.
Adobe gives every version of Adobe Commerce three years of standard support. Version 2.4.9 has standard support until 31 May 2029. For 2.4.6, standard support ended on 11 August 2026. Adobe Commerce customers keep extended support until 31 August 2027; that extension does not apply to Magento Open Source (as of 28 October 2026).
Yes. Migration tools transfer products, customers and orders, but custom work and extensions have to be rebuilt. With 301 redirects from every old URL to the new one, you carry over your Google rankings as well as possible.
For complex B2B with quotes, approvals and payment on account, Adobe Commerce is stronger. Shopify has B2B built in, with up to 3 catalogues on Basic, and that is enough for many wholesalers.